Qantas Tour of England - ODIs

'It's scaring me': ODI cricket's great debate

Cricket greats ask if limited-overs cricket has become too lopsided after a series of run fests in the United Kingdom


22 June 2018, 08:39 AM AEST

International limited overs batting records have been tumbling amid a blizzard of boundaries in recent weeks.

But while statisticians update their files an uncomfortable question remains: has the balance between bat and ball, on which all cricket depends, become worryingly lopsided in the one-day game?

Just over a week ago, New Zealand posted the highest ever total in a women's one-day international when they made 4-490 against Ireland in Dublin. Just days later, 17-year-old White Ferns allrounder Amelia Kerr broke the record for highest score with 232no.

And the women's Twenty20 International record fell twice in a day on Wednesday as New Zealand and then England piled up scores of 1-216 and 3-250 against South Africa at Taunton.

That came just 24 hours after England broke their own all-time men's ODI record when they made a mammoth 6-481 against Australia in Nottingham.

Even though world champions Australia were without six first-choice players through injury or suspension, it was still a staggering feat. 

Moreover, it meant England's previous men's ODI record total of 3-444 for three against Pakistan, also set at Trent Bridge, had lasted just two years.

WATCH: Every six from England's world record

It's all a far cry from the opening match of the inaugural men's World Cup in 1975 when England, in what was then a 60-over competition, made a then record 4-334 against India at Lord's.

India's Sunil Gavaskar thought the target so out of reach, the opening great carried his bat for 36 as his side managed 3-132 at the end of their 60 overs.

By contrast South Africa, when confronted with a then record score of 4-434 by Australia in 50 overs, the first time a team had passed 400 in an ODI, in Johannesburg in 2006, responded with 9-438.

But it is the latest record-breaking feat at Trent Bridge, a year out from the World Cup in England, that has sent shock waves through the world of cricket, given a total of 500 - once thought to be utterly unobtainable in a 50-over game - now appears to be in sight.

"To see almost 500 runs scored in 50 overs in England is scaring me ..about the health of the game and where it's going," tweeted former India captain Sourav Ganguly.

So how has it come to this?

While limits on the number of overs a bowler can deliver in an innings and fielding restrictions have long been a part of the one-day game, the really rapid increase in run-scoring has taken place during the last few years - England’s total at Trent Bridge was the eighth score of 400 or more since the start of 2015. Before that there had been just 11.

The advent of Twenty20, a new format which puts an emphasis on attacking batting, better bats, shorter boundaries and a greater range of shots such as "the scoop" and "the ramp", have all played their part in the increasing number of run-fests.

Similarly, rigid restrictions on field placings, limiting fielders on the boundary and the legside, have also worked against bowlers.

And one of the greatest changes has been the change to using two white balls, one from each end, during an innings.

Third ODI wrap: England maul Aussies, claim series

With all ODIs now played in coloured clothing, white balls have become a standard part of the limited overs game.

But they tend to swing less than traditional red cricket balls, making it easier for top-class batsmen to hit through the line.

It was thought having two white balls per innings would aid quicker bowlers as this would ensure bounce from both ends for longer in the innings.

Instead the effect has been to reduce the wear and tear which makes balls conducive to reverse swing, which has proven to be some of the most difficult bowling for batsmen to face.

James Anderson, England's all-time leading Test wicket-taker, who no longer plays limited overs cricket, said while commentating for BBC Radio on Tuesday: "I want to see a close game, a battle between bat and ball. 

"I love seeing batsmen in full flow, but I also like to see the off stump cartwheeling out of the ground. If the bowler bowled straight today he was going to get hit for six."

Meanwhile Michael Atherton, while admiring the "awesome combination of ease and brutality" displayed by England's batsmen in Nottingham,issued a plea on behalf of swing bowlers whom he felt had become "emasculated" in one-day cricket.

Writing in Thursday's edition of The Times, the former England captain and opening batsman insisted: "The game needs to find a suitable white ball that swings at the start and must abandon the use of two balls per innings, to allow for the return of reverse swing -— two fundamental skills of the game that provide as much entertainment as any number of sixes belted into the Nottingham night sky."

It was a view shared by Indian legend Sachin Tendulkar, who tweeted a game without reverse swing is a "perfect recipe for disaster".

Qantas tours of the UK and Zimbabwe

Australia ODI squad: Tim Paine (c), Aaron Finch (vc), Ashton Agar, Alex Carey, Travis Head, Nathan Lyon, Glenn Maxwell, Shaun Marsh, Michael Neser, Jhye Richardson, Kane Richardson, D’Arcy Short, Billy Stanlake, Marcus Stoinis, Andrew Tye

England ODI squad: Eoin Morgan (c), Moeen Ali, Jonny Bairstow, Jake Ball, Sam Billings, Jos Buttler, Sam Curran, Tom Curran, Alex Hales, Craig Overton, Liam Plunkett, Adil Rashid, Joe Root, Jason Roy, David Willey, Mark Wood

Australia T20 squad: Aaron Finch (c), Alex Carey (vc), Ashton Agar, Travis Head, Nic Maddinson, Glenn Maxwell, Jhye Richardson, Kane Richardson, D’Arcy Short, Billy Stanlake, Marcus Stoinis, Mitchell Swepson, Andrew Tye, Jack Wildermuth

England T20 squad: Eoin Morgan (c), Moeen Ali, Jonny Bairstow, Jake Ball, Jos Buttler, Sam Curran, Tom Curran, Alex Hales, Chris Jordan, Liam Plunkett, Adil Rashid, Joe Root, Jason Roy, David Willey

Qantas Tour of the UK

June 7: Australia beat Sussex by 57 runs at Hove

June 9: Australia beat Middlesex by 101 runs at Lord's

June 13: England won by three wickets at The Oval

June 16: England won by 38 runs in Cardiff

June 19: England won by 242 runs at Trent Bridge

June 21: England won by six wickets in Durham

June 24: Fifth ODI, Old Trafford

June 27: Only T20, Edgbaston (D/N)

Qantas T20I tri-series Tour of Zimbabwe

July 1: Zimbabwe vs Pakistan

July 2: Pakistan vs Australia

July 3: Australia vs Zimbabwe

July 4: Zimbabwe vs Pakistan

July 5: Pakistan vs Australia

July 6: Australia vs Zimbabwe

July 8: Final